(866) 777-2590Mon–Fri 9AM–6PM PST
FAST + FREE Shipping on orders above $999 · Lifetime Returns

FAST + FREE Shipping on orders above $999 · Lifetime Returns

Undercounter Ice Maker Guide: Clear vs Crescent Ice

An undercounter ice maker is a dedicated 15 inch appliance that makes and stores ice under a bar or outdoor kitchen counter, so you are not raiding the freezer before every party. Choosing one comes down to ice type (clear or crescent), daily production versus bin size, whether you have a floor drain, and indoor or outdoor use. Here is each one, using the Marvel machines we carry and Marvel’s spec sheets.

Clear ice maker vs regular ice maker: what is the difference?

“Regular” undercounter ice usually means crescent ice, the half moon shaped cube most home freezers make. Marvel describes its crescent machines as traditional ice makers that freeze water into shaped cubes and drop them into a storage bin. Marvel lists its crescent cube at 1/2 in wide, 3/4 in high and 2 1/4 in long.

A clear ice machine works differently. According to Marvel’s guide to ice types, water is frozen slowly in a slab so air is not trapped inside, then the slab slides onto a heated wire grid that cuts it into 3/4 in cubes. Marvel’s owner guide says the mineral rich leftover water drains after each cycle, which is why clear models need a drain.

U-Line’s ice guide describes clear ice as dense, slow melting and suited to premium cocktails, and crescent ice as the everyday choice for mixed drinks, sodas and iced tea that is less likely to clump. For whiskey and old fashioneds, clear ice is the upgrade. For poolside sodas, crescent is the practical, cheaper pick.

Our undercounter ice maker lineup compared

Model Ice type Daily production Bin storage Drain Our price
Marvel 15 in Crescent (MOCR215) Crescent 25 lb 25 lb None required $3,469
Marvel 15 in Clear, gravity drain (MOCL215) Clear, 3/4 in cube Up to 39 lb 28 lb (spec sheet) Gravity to floor drain $4,519
Marvel 15 in Clear, with pump (MOCP215) Clear, 3/4 in cube Up to 39 lb 28 lb (spec sheet) Factory installed pump $5,029

All three are Marvel outdoor collection models on 115V. Prices are our listed prices at the time of writing. Marvel’s own site shows suggested retail of $3,819 for the MOCR215, $4,979 for the MOCL215 and $5,539 for the MOCP215, so our listings were below Marvel’s suggested retail when we checked.

Marvel’s clear ice spec sheet says the bin stores up to 28 lb, while its product page lists 35 lb; we use the spec sheet. The 39 lb figure is Marvel’s rating at a 72 degree room with 55 degree water; in Eco mode Marvel rates the clear machine at up to 29 lb per day.

Daily production vs storage bin capacity

Daily production is what the machine makes in 24 hours; bin capacity is what it holds at once. When the bin is full the machine stops, and it restarts as you scoop.

For a party, the bin is what you have when guests arrive, and production is how fast it refills over the day, so start with a full bin. Marvel’s owner guide also says a new clear machine can take 24 to 48 hours to fill its bin after first startup, so do not install it the morning of an event.

Gravity drain vs drain pump ice maker: do you need a floor drain?

This is the question that decides which clear model you buy. Marvel’s spec sheet is direct: the factory installed drain pump model is required if a gravity drain is not available.

  • Gravity drain (MOCL215): water flows downhill on its own, so you need a drain lower than the machine’s outlet, typically a floor drain or a standpipe below the unit. It is the cheaper clear model.
  • Drain pump (MOCP215): a built in pump pushes water up and over to a sink drain or standpipe. Marvel’s guide lists maximum drain line lengths that shrink as the rise gets higher: 20 ft of line at 8 ft of rise, 15 ft at 9 ft and 10 ft at 10 ft. It also cuts power if the drain backs up, to help prevent flooding.
  • Crescent (MOCR215): Marvel says no pump or drain is required, which makes it the easiest retrofit in an existing island.

Either type must end at an open drain with an air gap, per Marvel. Marvel says to test it by pouring about 3 quarts of water into the empty bin.

Outdoor ice maker: what “outdoor rated” covers

Every Marvel machine above is listed as designed for outdoor use, but outdoor rated is not weatherproof in every climate. For the clear models, Marvel’s owner guide recommends a location out of direct sunlight and away from heat, gives a recommended room range of 55 to 90 degrees for built in installs, and says the machine will not perform correctly below 55 degrees. It also states that the warranty is voided if the unit is used at 40 degrees or below, so in cold climates plan to shut it down and drain it for winter.

Our outdoor wine fridge guide covers outdoor ratings in more depth, and the outdoor kitchen guide covers how to lay out the rest of the island.

15 inch ice maker installation: cutout, power and water

Cutout size

Marvel’s clear ice spec sheet gives a rough in opening of 15 in wide, 34 to 35 in high and 24 in deep. Our crescent listing gives a cutout of 15 1/4 in wide, 35 in high and 24 in deep. Both vent through the front grille, so keep it unblocked.

Electrical

Marvel calls for a grounded 115 volt, 15 amp dedicated circuit and warns against extension cords and adapters. Marvel notes GFCI outlets can nuisance trip, but outdoor outlets often must be GFCI protected by code, so follow your electrician.

Water line

For the clear models, Marvel specifies a cold, potable supply, water pressure between 20 and 120 psi, copper supply tubing, and a coiled service loop so the unit can be pulled out. Marvel does not recommend self piercing saddle valves because they tend to clog.

Cleaning and upkeep

Mineral scale builds up over time. Marvel recommends cleaning its clear machines about once every six months with a nickel safe ice machine cleaner, and the control shows a clean reminder. U-Line’s maintenance guide gives similar advice: use the maker’s approved cleaner, follow the manual and throw away the first batch of ice after cleaning.

Other options we carry

If you want nugget ice on a tighter budget, we list an undercounter nugget ice maker rated at 66 lb per day with 18 lb of storage, at about $1,229 at the time of writing. Its listing states no outdoor rating, so keep it indoors. For busy bars, commercial undercounter units such as the Manitowoc UDP0065A exist, but it is nearly 20 in wide and built for restaurants, not a 15 in home bay.

Pair it with a Marvel 15 in outdoor refrigerator or read our outdoor kegerator guide. Browse every Marvel appliance we carry, or start with our wine and home bar storage guide.

Frequently asked questions

Is a clear ice maker worth it over a regular ice maker?

If you serve spirits on the rocks often, it can be. On our listings the Marvel clear models cost about $1,050 to $1,560 more than the crescent model and need a drain. For sodas and casual drinks, crescent ice does the job.

Can I install a gravity drain ice maker without a floor drain?

No. Marvel says the pump model is required if a gravity drain is not available. The gravity model needs a drain below its outlet.

Can an outdoor ice maker stay outside all winter?

Not running. Marvel’s clear machines are not meant to run below 55 degrees, and use at 40 degrees or below voids the warranty.

Will a 15 inch ice maker fit where my trash pull-out is?

Often, if the opening is at least 15 in wide (15 1/4 in for the crescent), 34 to 35 in high and 24 in deep, with water, power and, for clear ice, a drain. Our 15 inch wine fridge guide covers measuring these bays.

Not sure which drain you need? Call us at 866-777-2590, Monday to Friday 9AM to 6PM PST. Orders of $999 or more ship free by freight, and you can review our return and refund policy before you buy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

✓ Authorized dealer for 200+ brands✓ Free shipping over $999✓ Lifetime return window✓ US-based support, Mon-Fri 9-6 PST✓ Secure checkout
Secure Site256-bit SSL encrypted
Safe CheckoutYour details stay private
Authorized Dealer200+ brands, factory-direct
Scroll to Top