(866) 777-2590Mon–Fri 9AM–6PM PST
FAST + FREE Shipping on orders above $999 · Lifetime Returns

FAST + FREE Shipping on orders above $999 · Lifetime Returns

Griddle vs Grill: Which to Put in an Outdoor Kitchen

Griddle vs grill comes down to what you cook most. A grill gives you sear marks, open flame and smoke flavor for steaks, chicken and charred burgers. A flat top griddle gives you a solid, evenly heated plate for smash burgers, pancakes, eggs, fried rice and anything small enough to fall through grates. If your outdoor kitchen has room for one appliance and you mostly cook meat, start with a grill and add a griddle insert. If breakfast and smash burgers are the main event, a built-in griddle earns its spot.

Griddle vs grill at a glance

Factor Built-in gas grill Built-in flat top griddle
Best foods Steaks, chops, chicken, kebabs, large cuts under the lid Smash burgers, breakfast, fried rice, shrimp, chopped vegetables
Flavor Sear marks, drippings hit the flame and add smoke Full surface crust, food cooks in its own fat
Heat zones One burner per zone, lid for indirect cooking Usually 2 burners under one plate: hot side and warm side
Cleanup Brush grates, empty drip tray Scrape into the grease tray, wipe, oil the plate
Upkeep Low Steel and cast iron plates need oil and seasoning
Example (NewAge specs) Platinum 33 in grill: up to 61,500 BTU Platinum 33 in griddle: 32,000 BTU, 441 sq in

What each cooking surface does well

Grates leave gaps. Fat drips onto the burners or flame tamers, vaporizes and rises back into the food, and the hot bars leave sear marks. The gaps also swallow eggs, diced onions and rice.

A griddle is one continuous plate. Every part of a burger patty touches hot metal, so you get an even brown crust instead of stripes. What you give up is the smoke from drippings and the ability to close a hood and roast a whole chicken.

Is a flat top griddle worth it?

Yes, if you cook breakfast outside, feed groups short-order food, or keep carrying a skillet out to the grill. If you mostly grill steaks a few times a month, try a griddle insert first.

Heat zones and control

A gas grill splits the firebox into separate burners, so you can sear on one side and cook indirectly on the other with the lid down. A griddle puts fewer burners under one plate. Each burner still makes a hotter area, so sear on the hot side and park finished food on the cooler side.

The NewAge Outdoor Kitchen Platinum 33 in Griddle (LP) pairs a 32,000 BTU dual burner system with a 9 mm thick cooking surface, 441 sq in of space and a stated maximum of 600 degrees F, according to NewAge. It is currently listed at about $2,100. The NewAge Platinum 33 in Grill (LP), listed at about $2,400, is rated by NewAge at up to 61,500 total BTU. Same width, very different jobs.

For a smaller island, the Kokomo Grills Professional 22 in Built-In Griddle Teppanyaki (about $2,499 at the time of writing) uses two U-shaped stainless burners for 36,000 BTU, plus a hood, Sure-Light ignition and a full-width stainless drip tray. Our listing gives 292.5 sq in of cooking surface: right for a family cookout, tight for a party.

Teppanyaki griddle vs round power burner griddle

The Sunstone 24 in Power Cirque Solid Steel Griddle Package (about $3,748) puts triple Cirque cast iron burners, rated up to 65,000 BTU, under a 19 in round solid steel griddle with an integrated oil pan. It suits stir fry style cooking in a compact module.

Cleanup, seasoning and grease management

Grills are forgiving: burn off residue, brush the grates, empty the drip tray now and then. Griddles need a routine. After each cook, scrape food and grease into the tray while the plate is warm, wipe it, then rub on a thin film of cooking oil. Steel and cast iron plates rely on that seasoning layer to resist rust and sticking. Follow the care steps in your owner’s manual, and empty the grease tray often, since a full tray is a fire risk.

Wind, weather and covers

An open flat top loses heat in a breeze, and rain on a warm steel plate invites rust. Plan for a cover from day one. For the NewAge griddle, the 33 in Platinum Griddle Cover is listed at about $110. The Kokomo has a built-in hood, and the Sunstone package includes a vinyl cover.

Fuel: LP vs NG built-in griddle for an outdoor kitchen

Built-in griddles and grills are sold as separate propane (LP) and natural gas (NG) versions. The NewAge griddle has an LP model and a separate NG model, each about $2,100. Order the version that matches your gas supply, and do not plan on a field conversion unless the manufacturer offers one for that exact model. Have a licensed gas fitter make the connection and leak test it to local code.

Cutout and island fit

NewAge lists the Platinum griddle at 33 in W x 25.2 in D x 16.11 in H and the 33 in Platinum grill at 33 in W x 25.2 in D x 25.4 in H. NewAge does not publish a cutout on the page we checked, so get the installation guide before the countertop is cut. Our Kokomo 22 in listing gives a cutout of 20 1/4 in W x 20 3/4 in D x 9 1/2 in H, and Sunstone specifies 22 3/4 in W x 22 1/2 in D x 10 in H. No island yet? The NewAge Platinum 33 in griddle with cart (about $2,500) stands on its own. Our built-in grill and outdoor kitchen guide covers layout, and our Cal Flame BBQ island guide shows how prebuilt islands handle appliance spacing.

The third option: a griddle insert for a grill or kamado

A griddle plate on your existing grill gives you most of the flat top benefits for far less money, with less surface and no dedicated burners.

Cast iron inserts need the same oil and seasoning routine. For more add-ons, see our Kamado Joe accessories guide; if you are still choosing the cooker itself, read pellet grill vs kamado. The full NewAge range is on our NewAge brand page.

Flat top griddle vs grill: which should you buy?

  • Grill: smoke flavor, sear marks, a lid for indirect cooking, low upkeep.
  • Built-in griddle: frequent breakfasts, smash burgers or hibachi style meals, and you will season the plate.
  • Grill plus insert: try griddle cooking before buying a second $2,000 appliance.
  • Both: your island has the width and gas supply, and you cook for groups.

Frequently asked questions

Can a griddle replace a grill?

For burgers, breakfast and stir fry style dishes, yes. For sear marks, smoke from drippings and covered cooking of large cuts, no.

Does a griddle insert for a grill work as well as a built-in griddle?

For small batches, yes. You get less surface and less even heat than a built-in griddle with its own burners and grease tray.

What is a teppanyaki griddle?

A flat steel plate, Japanese style, where food cooks directly on the surface. Built-in models like the Kokomo 22 in are gas fired and sized for an island.

Can I convert an LP griddle to natural gas?

Only if the manufacturer offers an approved conversion for that model. Otherwise buy the NG version and have a licensed gas fitter install it.

Questions about cutouts or fuel type? Call us at 866-777-2590, Mon to Fri 9AM to 6PM PST. Orders of $999 or more ship free by freight; orders below that ship for a flat $200. See our return and refund policy before you order.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

✓ Authorized dealer for 200+ brands✓ Free shipping over $999✓ Lifetime return window✓ US-based support, Mon-Fri 9-6 PST✓ Secure checkout
Secure Site256-bit SSL encrypted
Safe CheckoutYour details stay private
Authorized Dealer200+ brands, factory-direct
Scroll to Top